The Rosenhan experiment: crazy very sane

Can you imagine faking a dementia to enter a psychiatric and then not believe you when you stop simulating that madness? This is what happened in the Rosenhan experiment .And, as economist Paul Anthony Samuelson said:

“When everyone is crazy, being sane is crazy ”

In 1973, the prestigious journal Science published a study that called into question the validity of the psychiatric diagnosis It was the article "Be sane in insane places", which reflects the experiment that the psychologist David Rosenham had conducted between 1968 and 1972 in a dozen psychiatric centers in five states of the United States.

In Lifestyle we tell you what this peculiar test consists of.

First phase: infiltrates

In the first stage of the trial, a dozen totally stringent people and without a history of mental illness pretended to suffer acoustic hallucinations, that is, they assured that they heard voices that were nonexistent, p To enter psychiatric throughout the country and all classes (old, modern, rural, urban, public, private...).

Needless to say, hospitals were unaware that they were being studied and that the volunteers in the experiment altered their names and, in some cases, their professions, keeping the rest of their lives true to reality.

The Rosenhan experiment: crazy very sane

Everyone was diagnosed as insane , despite not being, and they got their respective places in the centers.

Returning to sanity

Then the pseudo-crazy stopped simulating those hallucinations and began to behave with normal, indicating it to the psychiatric staff.

Nobody believed them.Well, to be more exact, numerous mentally ill of the centers if they perceived sanity of the imposters and c They argued that the fake patients were infiltrated and that they were journalists or investigators, since Rosenhan's volunteers went with a notebook and wrote notes on it during their internment.This practice, however, was considered pathological for nurses and caregivers. Curious, isn't it?

Moreover, in no case did the volunteers of the experiment get discharged and, in fact, to leave the hospitals they had to sign a acknowledgment of their mental illness and commit to medicating with antipsychotics.Some of the participants were two months in detention , despite their "improvement", although the average was about three weeks.

"I said to my friends, to my family: 'I will leave there when I have to leave, that is all.I will be there a couple of days and then I will leave.' No one had any idea what would happen two months there! The only way out was to accept that they were right.'They say that I am crazy, because I am, but I am improving.' It was an affirmation of the image they had of me, ”said Rosenhan himself about his project..

Second phase: the test, to the test

But the lesson was not there.A university hospital in the country, incredulous at the malpractice of his companions, asked Rosenham to send healthy incognito patients to discover them .

The Rosenhan experiment: crazy very sane

What was the surprise when the management of this center assured that it had detected 41 pseudopatients , 19 of them with the suspicion of at least two workers, among the almost 200 people who attended the center in the following three months.

The disappointment is that Rosenham had not sent anyone to the hospital.Didn't the suggestion allow them to do their job well? That seems.Those who are not and ropes that do not exist.Surely you are also interested in this article about five personalities with mental disorders.

The consequences

This behavior, for Rosenham, showed that mental illness is not conceived in psychiatry as a curable disease, but a stigma that pursues patients for the rest of their lives.

The psychologist also criticized the dehumanized treatment offered to patients, with a few minutes of daily attention, and the lack of skepticism shown by the staff.

Obviously, their conclusions were like a bomb in the world of Psychiatry and, overcome the polemic, the experiment Rosenham allowed the change of the manuals of psychiatric diagnosis and the doctor-patient relationship, promoting the movement of the so-called antipsychiatry and the deinstitutionalization of the treatment of the mentally ill.

And if you've been wanting to continue your visit to the psychiatric , I recommend this article.

And you? Have you been taken as crazy on occasion when you weren't?

Images: Nicolas Fuentes , zentolos, Ricardo Alguacil

Comments

Do you only see 1 point? There are 12! More optical illusions and their explanation

At Lifestyle we love the optical illusions and its scientific explanations.On other occasions we have talked about the incredible Troxler effect and other optical illusions that have become viral.This time we bring you this panel that hides 12 points at the intersections , but we are unable to see all at once.Do you only see 1 point? There are 12! Here you have more optical illusions and their explanation. Do you only see 1 point? There are 12! More optical illusions and their explanation This image that was actually made public in 2000 by the magazine «Perception» has gone viral in a few days by sharing it on its Facebook the Japanese psychologist Akiyoshi Kitaoka. It is impossible to see all twelve points at once .If you look at a section, you may see 4 or 5 points in the drawing, but the twelve is Impossible.According to experts, this phenomenon is due to the way our peripheral vision acts.When we focus our eyes on something that is outside the field of vision, it is ...

Harvard presents 4 ways for your children to be kind

One of the things that undoubtedly worries us as parents is the education of our children .While there has been some progress in educating them in greater freedom and love, it is also true that one more formation Focused on success and personal happiness, or on achieving good grades, it has led to the emergence of a more selfish and less supportive generation . Somehow, get that our children are also good people is a challenge, because they must achieve for themselves-helped and guided by us, of course-the delicate balance between the "I" and the collective, between training as conscious individuals and as beings that they are part of a group, of a society. But according to a study carried out by the Harvard School of Education, a project known as Making Caring Common where they interviewed 10,000 students (primary and secondary school) ), most young people think it is more important and he personal success and his own happiness that caring and caring for others, being...

Are cats dangerous to the health of a pregnant woman?

Cats are one of the best known transmitters of toxoplasmosis , a disease that can be very dangerous for a pregnant woman.However, taking appropriate precautions, If you have a cat at home, it should not represent a greater danger. What is toxoplasmosis? Toxoplasmosis is an infectious disease caused by an intracellular parasite, the consequences can range from mild reactions to cause congenital malformations and even death in the case of fetuses.It is important to remember that toxoplasmosis it is transmitted through the mother's bloodstream to the baby. The chances of a woman infected with toxoplasmosis transmitting the disease to her baby increase depending on the period of pregnancy you are in.If the woman contracts the disease in the first trimester the fetus has a 15% chance of becoming infected; if it occurs in the second trimester the odds increase to 30% and if it is in the third trimester there is up to 60% chance that the baby will also get the di...

Is it true that dogs can smell diseases?

There are many studies about this suspicion.Can a dog smell for example that we are about to suffer an epilepsy attack? Or what is going to lower our sugar level? It may surprise you, but it seems that it is so.Our beloved pets rise once more like those great friends who at any time, can save our lives. Let's see now some of the diseases that dogs can detect: Narcolepsy Narcolepsy is the disease of sleep.A small part of the population suffers, and It occurs in people who, when they suffer or experience an emotion, instantly fall asleep.The Institute for Investigation of Sleep Disorders , tells us that patients who suffer from it have a smell Especially surprisingly enough, it has been shown that dogs trained for detecting police narcotics are the first to identify when a person is about to suffer a narcolepsy attack. Chlostridium difficile A strange name for a type of bacteria capable of causing a serious infection, with significant diarrhea capable of leaving us...

«Jumbo Stay», The Boeing 747 turned into a hotel

Are you looking for an original destination to go on vacation? Are you perhaps a lover of aeronautics ? Then you will love to know the Jumbo Hotel of Sweden .A fascinating adventure that will allow you to spend a few days inside a fantastic plane that despite having no destination and not extending its fabulous wings any more the sky, will allow you to sound through the ground through its windows, its narrow aisles, its minuscule compartments but always comfortable...and above all, share it with other aircraft fans like you. The Jumbo Stay in Stockholm, the plane without a flight route Raise your dreams and imagine the most curious hotel , unique and new in the world.There are hotels made exclusively of ice, accommodation in narrow lighthouses in the middle of the sea, hotels up in the treetops and even in old haunted castles...so, why not in a plane? Of course. Restaurant of the Hotel-Avion This airplane-hotel is located in the airport of Stockholm Arlanda (just over 42km...

Could there be a zombie virus? Create undead? Find it out!

We all know what zombies are; those horrible undead who wander aimlessly looking for food...brains, meat...But, could there really be a zombie virus? A virus capable of creating zombies? Find out! Could there be a zombie virus? Create undead? Find out! Samita Andreasky, a virologist from the University of Miami, met with National Geographic to discuss the progress of her work called “the truth about zombies.” The doctor says that although It is extremely difficult to produce a zombie virus, it could happen. The zombie virus would be a combination of the rabies virus with others like the flu and Ebola, among many others .The first two would allow the disease to be transmitted through the air, if that of rabies is mixed with that of measles it can cause personality changes, with that of encephalitis it would produce aggressiveness and very high fevers, and if we add the ebola we would have infected who bleed in spurts, as shown in the series and movies. Getting all these co...

What is pop art?

It all sounds to us when they talk to us about “Pop” and we tend to relate it to pop music, however it was an important artistic movement of the twentieth century, a kind of modern art.Do you want to know more about the pop art ? Continue reading the following article and leave us your opinions on this topic. Pop art or better known as the " Pop art " is a related movement with the art that was born in the late fifties.The cities of London, in England and New York in the United States, are considered the most important cradles of pop art. The work of Andy Warhol The American artist Andy Warhol was an avant-garde at the time when he placed himself with his work as one of the main references of this movement.Through it he tried to eliminate from the work of art any sign of craftsmanship, that's why most of his works are made from photographs projected on the canvas.One of his most famous paintings is the one that portrays Marilyn Monroe , later converted into an...

5 stupid Lottery winners

Hello Lifestyle ! Before reading the article we would like you to know a new way to discover our curious world, through Youtube ! We have a channel that we would love to be a part of.You can subscribe and meet him here-> YouTube Lifestyle! Even if we are not fond of spending our money on gambling, who has not sounded on any occasion that he played the lottery ? Who has not let the imagination fly thinking that he would do with the prize money? Apparently it is not so easy to make common sense when those huge amounts of money fall into our hands.The demonstration is in the stories of these 5 stupid Lottery winners . 5 stupid Lottery winners 1.Willie Hurt Willie lived in Michigan and He led an absolutely conventional life.He was married, he was a good father, he had a steady job and he went to church.In 1989, $ 3.1 million was played in the lottery.the way the money was paid in annual installments of $ 156,000.But the prize upset . He started the divorce pro...

Diabetes, the silent disease that can attack you without you noticing

Diabetes is a chronic disease that manifests when the pancreas does not synthesize enough insulin for the body or is not used properly.Insulin, in turn, is the hormone whose main function is to maintain the values adequate blood glucose, transforming the sugar, starch and other foods into the energy that we require for the development of our daily lives.It is for this reason that in people suffering from diabetes there is an excess of blood glucose , also known as hyperglycemia . Diabetes is a silent disease that can attack you at any time , radically changing your lifestyle.For this reason, you must stay alert and thus be able to perceive any signal of its presence.In case of being one of those affected by this disease, you should follow an adequate and controlled medical treatment; otherwise, the tissues could end up damaged and cause serious complications for your body, however, with proper treatment, many people with diabetes can prevent or delay the onset of these complicatio...

Lifestyle Libre

Search This Blog